New Forest Safety Ltd

Insights

The Swiss Cheese Model: Why Accidents Are Rarely Caused by Just One Thing

19 August 2026 · Harriet Calvert

Most serious incidents don't occur because a single control fails. They happen when several small weaknesses align at exactly the wrong moment.

When people investigate workplace accidents, there is often a temptation to search for a single cause. A procedure wasn't followed. A machine malfunctioned. Someone forgot to wear the correct personal protective equipment. Identifying one clear reason provides a sense of closure and creates the impression that the problem has been solved.

Unfortunately, workplace accidents are rarely that simple.

Health and safety professionals have long recognised that serious incidents almost never result from a single failure. Instead, they develop through a combination of events, decisions and conditions that gradually erode the layers of protection designed to keep people safe. Each weakness on its own may appear insignificant, but when several occur at the same time, the opportunity for an accident increases dramatically.

One of the most influential ways of understanding this process is the Swiss Cheese Model, developed by Professor James Reason in the early 1990s. Although originally associated with aviation and high-risk industries, the model has become a cornerstone of modern health and safety management because it reflects the reality of how accidents occur across construction, manufacturing, logistics, engineering and countless other sectors.

At New Forest Safety, we regularly use this way of thinking when investigating incidents and reviewing safety management systems. Rather than asking which control failed, we examine how multiple controls interacted and why they were unable to prevent the event. This approach leads to more meaningful improvements because it recognises that accidents are usually symptoms of wider organisational issues rather than isolated mistakes.

Understanding the Model

The Swiss Cheese Model is deceptively simple.

Imagine that every safety control within your organisation is represented by a slice of Swiss cheese. One slice might represent training, another supervision, another risk assessments, another maintenance, and another safe systems of work.

Each slice provides a barrier between workplace hazards and the people exposed to them.

However, none of these barriers is perfect.

Every slice contains holes.

Those holes represent weaknesses. A risk assessment may be out of date. A supervisor may be absent. Equipment may not have been inspected as frequently as planned. A procedure may be difficult to follow in practice. A new employee may not yet have developed sufficient experience.

Individually, these weaknesses rarely result in an accident because the remaining layers continue to provide protection.

The problem arises when the holes temporarily line up.

When several barriers fail at the same time, a hazard is able to pass through every layer, resulting in an incident that, from the outside, may appear to have been caused by a single mistake.

Looking Beyond the Final Event

Imagine a worker falls from height while carrying out maintenance on a roof.

A traditional investigation might conclude that the individual failed to use the correct fall protection equipment.

The Swiss Cheese Model encourages us to look much further.

Was the work properly planned?

Had a suitable risk assessment been completed?

Was the equipment readily available?

Had supervisors checked the work before it began?

Did the maintenance schedule create unnecessary time pressure?

Could the task have been designed so that working at height was avoided altogether?

Each of these questions represents another layer of defence.

The worker's decision was simply the final event in a much longer chain.

By understanding every contributing factor, organisations are able to strengthen multiple areas rather than relying solely on retraining the individual involved.

Safety Controls Are Designed to Work Together

One of the greatest strengths of the Swiss Cheese Model is that it reminds us safety controls should never operate in isolation.

Risk assessments identify hazards before work begins.

Training ensures people understand those hazards.

Supervision provides oversight during the task.

Maintenance ensures equipment remains safe.

Audits verify that systems continue to function as intended.

Communication allows concerns to be raised quickly.

Each control supports the others.

If one becomes weaker, the remaining controls often prevent an incident.

This is why organisations should avoid placing too much reliance on a single measure, particularly administrative controls such as procedures or training. While these are important, they are generally less reliable than eliminating hazards through design or introducing engineering controls that reduce dependence on human behaviour.

This principle is reflected throughout modern risk management and is one reason the hierarchy of control remains such an important part of health and safety practice.

Construction Demonstrates the Model Perfectly

Few industries illustrate the Swiss Cheese Model more clearly than construction.

Consider a lifting operation involving a mobile crane.

The lift plan has been prepared.

The crane operator is competent.

The lifting accessories have been inspected.

A banksman is present.

Weather conditions have been assessed.

The exclusion zone has been established.

Each of these controls forms one layer of protection.

Now imagine several small weaknesses emerge.

The delivery programme falls behind schedule, creating pressure to complete the lift quickly. A subcontractor unfamiliar with the site enters the exclusion zone. Communication becomes more difficult because of background noise. The lift supervisor is temporarily distracted by another issue.

None of these problems necessarily causes an accident.

Together, however, they significantly increase the likelihood of one occurring.

This is precisely why the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 emphasise planning, coordination and cooperation. Effective communication between clients, designers, principal contractors and Principal Designers creates additional layers of defence long before construction begins.

As Principal Designers, New Forest Safety works with project teams to identify foreseeable risks during design and ensure that safety controls complement one another rather than operating independently. Good planning reduces the likelihood that those weaknesses will ever align.

Weak Signals Should Never Be Ignored

One of the lessons the Swiss Cheese Model teaches us is that small problems deserve attention.

A missing guardrail.

A faulty light.

An incomplete permit.

An outdated drawing.

A delayed inspection.

Each may seem insignificant when viewed on its own.

However, every weakness increases the size of one of the holes within the organisation's safety defences.

This is why near miss reporting, workplace inspections and routine audits are so valuable. They help identify weaknesses while there is still time to address them.

Waiting until several failures combine often means waiting until someone has already been injured.

Strong Organisations Expect Imperfection

Perhaps the most important message within the Swiss Cheese Model is that no organisation can eliminate every weakness.

Procedures will occasionally be misunderstood.

Equipment will sometimes fail.

People will make mistakes.

Conditions will change.

The objective is not perfection.

It is resilience.

High-performing organisations recognise that failures are inevitable and design systems capable of preventing a single weakness from escalating into a serious incident.

Rather than relying on one control, they create multiple independent layers of protection so that if one fails, others remain in place.

This philosophy underpins many of the world's safest industries, from aviation and nuclear power to healthcare and construction.

How New Forest Safety Can Help

At New Forest Safety, we believe effective health and safety management is about understanding how systems perform under real working conditions.

Whether we're carrying out an independent audit, investigating an incident or supporting a construction project as Principal Designer, we look beyond individual failures to understand how organisational systems interact.

Our audits examine whether safety controls genuinely support one another or whether gaps are beginning to emerge between policies, procedures and day-to-day practice. We help organisations strengthen those layers before weaknesses align and create the conditions for an accident.

This systems-based approach not only improves compliance but also builds more resilient organisations capable of adapting to change without compromising safety.

Final Thoughts

The Swiss Cheese Model has remained influential for more than three decades because it reflects an important truth about workplace safety.

Accidents rarely occur because one person makes one mistake.

More often, they happen because several weaknesses exist within the organisation at the same time. Individually, those weaknesses appear manageable. Together, they create an opportunity for harm.

The safest organisations understand that every inspection, every maintenance activity, every conversation about safety and every near miss report strengthens one of those protective layers. By continually improving each layer, they make it increasingly difficult for hazards to pass all the way through the system.

At New Forest Safety, this philosophy shapes the way we support our clients. Rather than focusing on isolated failures, we help organisations build robust, interconnected safety systems that remain effective even when individual controls are challenged. After all, good health and safety is rarely about one decision, it is about ensuring that every layer of protection works together to keep people safe.

← All insights